Dialectic vs Dialogic – A very brief explanation
- 0
I’ve come across these two terms quite often, so whats the difference?
Dialectic:
- Dialectic: a process where opposing ideas or perspectives clash, leading to the eventual dominance of one. In classical dialectics (especially in Hegel), it’s not just about one perspective winning; rather, the two conflicting ideas (thesis and antithesis) often merge or synthesize into a new understanding (synthesis).
- This process can lead to progression of thought, moving toward greater understanding.
In short: Conflict leads to a resolution where a synthesis of ideas emerges, driving progress (e.g., Hegel’s thesis-antithesis-synthesis model) or the dominance of one perspective over another
Dialogic:
- A space where multiple perspectives coexist without the pressure for one to dominate. More focus on open-ended exchange and understanding rather than a final resolution or synthesis. The interaction is shaped by circumstances, context, and interpersonal factors (like emotions, ethics, and goals).
In short: Multiple viewpoints coexist and can be relativist, and there is no drive for one “best” idea to prevail; the goal is engagement and exchange.
Author
Related Posts
Science and Technology Studies – A quick Introduction
Discover the origins and key concepts of Science and Technology Studies (STS) in this overview, based on Sismondo's work. Explore how STS...
Read out allQ & A: (Post-)Positivism, Critical Theory & Constructivism
Have you wondered about middle range and grand theories? The difference between interpretivism and constructivism? Here you can find the answers!
Read out allThe “Turns” in Social Science
Learn more about the major intellectual shifts, such as linguistic, cultural, material and ontological turn
Read out allPodcasts on Philosophy and Sociology
Do you learn through listening? Here are my recommended podcasts about philosophy and sociology
Read out allSociology/ Social Science/ Culture Studies…Humanities?
Learn about the difference between sociology, social sciences, culture studies and humanities.
Read out allInfrastructure studies, platform studies, software studies, media studies, (critical) data studies – what are they about?!
I’ve been looking in several traditions and fields, some that are recurring are infrastructure studies, software studies, media studies, data studies (as...
Read out all